407 Proxy Authentication Required: 407 vs 403 vs 429
407 means your proxy refused you; 403 and 429 usually come from the site. Real responses from Squid, three anti-bot systems and GitHub.
How automated traffic is identified, layer by layer, and which layers a different address actually affects.
The single most useful thing to understand about blocking is that it happens in stages, and each stage is cheaper for the defender than the next. Work out which one refused you and the next step is obvious. Guess, and you will spend money on proxies to fix a problem proxies cannot reach.
| Layer | Decides on | Does a new address help? |
|---|---|---|
| Network reputation | The ASN and address history | Yes, if the new address is classified differently |
| Transport | The TLS handshake | No. The handshake is unchanged |
| Protocol | Header set, order and HTTP version | No |
| Behaviour | Timing, paths, volume per identity | Resets the counter, not the pattern |
| Client challenge | JavaScript execution, CAPTCHA | No |
Only the first and fourth rows respond to a new address at all. This is why "we switched to residential proxies and still get blocked" is such a common report: the decision was never about where the request appeared to come from.
The first message of a TLS connection is sent in plain text before any encryption, and it lists the cipher suites and extensions your TLS library supports, in your library's order. That is emitted before you have sent a single header, so the classification is finished before the user agent ever arrives.
We measured how far apart the clients actually are. A byte-level capture of nine HTTP clients and a browser found the browser sending eleven headers against a median of four, no two clients producing the same header order, and two clients sending no user agent at all. None of it changes with a proxy.
The response itself narrows the cause considerably:
The status-code guide covers the three refusals you will meet most often and what each one obliges you to do differently.
Fingerprinting rewards ordinariness and punishes contradiction. No single property is rare; the combination is. Changing one value to something unusual does not blend you in, it moves you to a smaller group.
This is why partial disguise reliably backfires. A browser user agent over a library handshake, or an exit in one country with a browser reporting another country's timezone, is more distinctive than sending nothing at all.
407 means your proxy refused you; 403 and 429 usually come from the site. Real responses from Squid, three anti-bot systems and GitHub.
We loaded one local page 80 times in 16 Chrome, Playwright and Puppeteer setups and recorded what each exposed to bot detection.
We checked eight free IP blocklists against each other. 93.7% of individually listed addresses were on only one of the six primary lists.
Chromium produced 12 different JA3-style hashes in 12 connections. curl and Go kept one order across 3 each; five other libraries were sampled once.
Error 1020 is Cloudflare's 403 for a request a site's security settings blocked. How to read it, tell it from proxy errors, and get…
Cloudflare error 1006 means the site owner banned your IP; 1010 means your client signature. How to tell them from proxy and WebSocket 1006…
Error 1015 "You are being rate limited" is Cloudflare enforcing a site owner's rate limit. Real captures, every cause, and the fix for each.
HTTP 418 I'm a teapot is a reserved joke code. Why real sites, WAFs and APIs still send it to scrapers, a local repro,…
HTTP 444 is nginx's silent connection close, so clients see an empty reply instead of an HTTP response. Find the edge rule before retrying.
We re-captured the TLS ClientHello from 19 clients on 2026-10-21. Chrome 155 changed JA3 on all 24 connections; JA4 never changed.
Nine HTTP clients and a browser, captured at the byte level. The browser sent 11 headers; the median library sent 4, in a different…
A test a website shows when it doubts that a visitor is human, from distorted text and image grids to a single checkbox.
A honeypot link is a link placed where no human visitor will see or follow it, so that any client requesting it reveals itself…
Software in front of a website that scores each request on its network, TLS handshake, headers and behaviour, then serves, challenges or blocks it.
Identifying a visitor from properties a page's JavaScript can read, such as screen, GPU, plugins, languages and timezone, combined into one profile.
An HTTP/2 fingerprint identifies a client from the settings, window size and pseudo-header order it uses to open a connection, not from header values.
Identifying the software behind a connection from its TLS ClientHello, which is sent in the clear before any HTTP header.
We ran Squid, Apache, glider, Go's ReverseProxy and socat in front of a raw listener. None added X-Real-IP; four of nine defaults added X-Forwarded-For.